- Price cut 3%
495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City, UT 84028
$899,000
Originally listed at $929,000
Est. $5,358/mo
- Beds
- 4
- Baths
- 4
- Sq ft
- 4,116
- Built
- 2000
Why this home stands out
- 3% price reduction from original list
- 91.0 days on market — potential negotiation opportunity
About this home
Welcome to Buttercup Lane, a peaceful mountain retreat perched above Bear Lake, where breathtaking panoramic views, exceptional gathering spaces, and endless recreation come together in one remarkable property. Tucked away at the end of a quiet road with no HOA, this beautifully maintained log home captures sweeping views of Bear Lake, Garden City, and the picturesque farmland below, complete with a seasonal creek meandering along the property's lower boundary. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, second home, executive retreat, or high-performing vacation rental, this property offers incredible versatility. Featuring 4 bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms, the home comfortably accommodates up to 16 guests, including a luxurious California King primary suite and a spacious bunk room. Inside, vaulted ceilings, a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, and expansive windows create a warm, inviting great room while showcasing spectacular lake views. A beautiful combination of log walls and finished drywall provides the perfect balance of rustic mountain charm and modern comfort. The spacious kitchen opens seamlessly to the dining area, featuring a charming shiplap accent wall, generous seating, and an oversized island with bar seating-ideal for entertaining family and friends. Just outside, the expansive covered deck offers front-row seats to unforgettable sunrises, sunsets, and panoramic lake views. Designed for year-round enjoyment, the home includes multiple living spaces, including a large theater/family room, game room, and a cozy wood-burning stove for relaxing after a day on the ski slopes or nearby snowmobile trails. An oversized two-car garage, two large laundry rooms, and a separate flex/utility garage with drive-in access for side-by-sides, ATVs, or snowmobiles provide exceptional convenience and abundant storage for every adventure. Located just minutes from Bear Lake's beaches, boating, skiing, hiking, a local Playhouse and year-round recreation, Buttercup Lane offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and investment potential in one of Northern Utah's premier vacation destinations. All offers will be considered.
Features
- Fireplace
- Bath: Primary
- Great Room
- Kitchen: Updated
- Basement Entrance
- Deck; Covered
- Double Pane Windows
- Lighting
- Patio: Covered
- Porch: Open
- Sliding Glass Doors
- Walkout
Agents
Connect with your buyer agent
Get local guidance on this home from Juston.
Salt Lake County Realtor | Smart Real Estate. Lasting Legacy.
20 yrs experience
Listed by Joni Kartchner
RE/MAX Peaks
MLS #2177045
Your message goes only to Juston.
See the deal analysis, value and rental income
Ask Juston how this home rates as a deal, what it should sell for, and what it could earn as a long-term or short-term rental.
- Deal score
- Estimated value
- Rental income
Schools
Rich- North Rich
Elementary
- Rich
Middle School
- Rich
High School
Nearby
Recreation
83 / 100- Local Park · Heritage Park1837 ft
- State Park · Bear Lake State Park2.1 mi
- Boat Ramp · Bear Lake State Park2.2 mi
- Golf Course · Bear Lake Golf Course2.4 mi
Show 3 more
- Trailhead · Limber Pine Nature3.6 mi
- Lake · Bear Lake4.6 mi
- Ski Resort · Beaver Mountain Resort8.0 mi
Everyday needs
94 / 100- Park · Heritage Park2165 ft
- Doctors · Bear Lake Clinic0.7 mi
- Pharmacy · Bear Lake Drug Garden City0.7 mi
- Gas Station · Chevron0.9 mi
Show 7 more
- Restaurant · Bear Lake Pizza Co0.9 mi
- Cafe · Moose Buns1.0 mi
- Fire Station · Garden City Fire District1.0 mi
- EV Charging · ChargePoint Charging Station1.0 mi
- Grocery · Bear Lake Market1.1 mi
- Gym · The Shed Fit 3651.3 mi
- Bank · Zions Bank1.6 mi
Internet
Excellent · 85/100CentraCom
Fixed Wireless · 500 Mbps
Verizon
Fixed Wireless · 300 Mbps
Starlink
Satellite · 280 Mbps
All 6 providers
- CentraComFixed Wireless500 Mbps100 Mbps
- VerizonFixed Wireless300 Mbps20 Mbps
- StarlinkSatellite280 Mbps30 Mbps
- HughesNetSatellite100 Mbps5 Mbps
- T-MobileFixed Wireless100 Mbps20 Mbps
- Viasat IncSatellite25 Mbps3 Mbps
- CentraComDSL10 Mbps1 Mbps
Home details
Property
- Type
- Residential
- Style
- Single Family Residence
- Architectural style
- Rambler/Ranch
- Year built
- 2000
- Stories
- 2
- Above grade area
- 1,776 sq ft
- Condition
- Blt./Standing
- Construction
- Log,Stone
- Subdivision
- BUTTERCUP ESTATES
- County
- Rich
- Zoning
- Single-Family, Short Term Rental Allowed
- MLS #
- 2177045
Costs
- List price
- $899,000
- Original price
- $929,000
- Annual taxes
- $3,137
- Home warranty
- No
Lot and parking
- Lot
- 0.51 ac
- Lot features
- Road: Paved,Terrain: Grad Slope,View: Lake,View: Mountain,View: Valley,View: Water
- Garage
- 2 cars
- Covered spaces
- 2
- Total parking
- 6
Systems
- Heating
- Forced Air,Gas: Central,Hot Water,Propane,Wood
- Cooling
- Central Air,Natural Ventilation,Passive Solar
- Roof
- Metal
- Flooring
- Carpet,Slate
- Basement
- Walk-Out Access
- Appliances
- Ceiling Fan,Portable Dishwasher,Microwave
- Laundry
- Electric Dryer Hookup
- Patio and porch
- Covered,Porch: Open
- Water
- Culinary
- View
- Lake,Mountain(s),Valley
All home details59 details
Property Info
- Property Type
- Residential
- Property Style
- Single Family Residence
- Architectural Style
- Rambler/Ranch
- Condition
- Blt./Standing
- MLS #
- 2177045
- County
- Rich
- Subdivision
- BUTTERCUP ESTATES
- Year Built
- 2000
- New Construction
- No
- Stories
- 2
- Total Rooms
- 15
- Living Area
- 4,116 sq ft
- Above Grade Area
- 1,776 sq ft
- Lot Size (Acres)
- 0.51
- Lot Size
- 22,215.6 sq ft
- Zoning
- Single-Family, Short Term Rental Allowed
Bedrooms & Baths
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Total Bathrooms
- 4
- Full Baths
- 4
Financial
- List Price
- $899,000
- Original Price
- $929,000
- HOA
- No
- Annual Taxes
- $3,137
- Home Warranty
- No
Structure
- Construction
- Log,Stone
- Basement
- Walk-Out Access
- Roof
- Metal
- Flooring
- Carpet,Slate
- Heating
- Forced Air,Gas: Central,Hot Water,Propane,Wood
- Cooling
- Central Air,Natural Ventilation,Passive Solar
- Appliances
- Ceiling Fan,Portable Dishwasher,Microwave
- Laundry
- Electric Dryer Hookup
- Patio & Porch
- Covered,Porch: Open
Lot & Land
- Lot Features
- Road: Paved,Terrain: Grad Slope,View: Lake,View: Mountain,View: Valley,View: Water
- Topography
- Road: Paved, Terrain, Flat, Terrain: Grad Slope, View: Lake, View: Mountain, View: Valley, View: Water
- View
- Lake,Mountain(s),Valley
- Waterfront
- No
- Horse Property
- No
Parking
- Garage
- Yes
- Garage Spaces
- 2
- Carport
- No
- Covered Spaces
- 2
- Open Parking
- 4
- Total Parking
- 6
- ADU
- No
Amenities
- Fireplace
- Yes
- Fireplaces
- 1
- Pool
- No
- Spa/Hot Tub
- No
- Inclusions
- Ceiling Fan, Dishwasher: Portable, Microwave, Range, Window Coverings, Wood Stove
Utilities
- Water Source
- Culinary
- Utilities
- Natural Gas Connected,Electricity Connected,Water Connected
Schools
- Elementary
- North Rich
- Middle School
- Rich
- High School
- Rich
- Elementary District
- Rich
Timeline
- Listed
- Jul 6, 2026
- Days on Market
- 91
- Status
- Active
Garden City market
Explore Garden CityGarden City median
$525,000
This home: 71% above
Days to sell
163
Utah: 70
Homes for sale
162
Price range
$65k – $4.4M
Sale to list
95%
Market
Buyer's market
Location
BUTTERCUP ESTATES495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City, UT 84028
Open in map searchCommon questions
About 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City, UtahWhat is the asking price for 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City?
495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City is listed at $899,000 ($218/sqft). The original list price was $929,000, representing a reduction of $30,000. This listing is currently active and available for showings.
Is 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City a good deal?
Propaired's AI deal analysis classifies this property as a "Standard" with a deal score of 50/100. Key deal signals: 3% price reduction from original list; 91.0 days on market — potential negotiation opportunity. The price is 21% above similar homes in the area. This analysis considers price relative to comparables, days on market, price reductions, and market conditions.
Is 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City a good investment property?
Based on market rental data, this property has an estimated annual rent of $36,609 with a gross rental yield of 4.1%. Net rental yield (after estimated expenses): 2.6%. Estimated debt service coverage ratio (DSCR): 0.55. Investor score: 30/100. These are estimates based on area comparables.
What lifestyle features does 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City offer?
Propaired's AI has identified 6 lifestyle features for this property: Near Skiing, Cabin & Mountain, OHV & ATV Trails, Scenic Views, Investor Special, Short-Term Rental. The primary lifestyle niche is "cabin_mountain." These tags are derived from MLS data, property features, and location analysis.
What recreation is near 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City?
This property has a recreation score of 83/100. Nearby recreation includes: Limber Pine Nature trailhead (3.6 mi); Heritage Park park (0.3 mi); Bear Lake Golf Course (2.4 mi); Bear Lake State Park (2.1 mi). Skiing: Beaver Mountain Resort (8.0 mi). Utah offers world-class outdoor recreation year-round, from skiing to hiking to national parks.
What amenities and services are near 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City?
This property has an amenity proximity score of 94/100. Nearby services include: Grocery: Bear Lake Market (1.1 mi); Hospital: Keith W. Kent, NP (23.8 mi); Pharmacy: Bear Lake Drug Garden City (0.7 mi); Dining: Bear Lake Pizza Co (0.9 mi). Gas station: 0.9 miles. Gym: The Shed Fit 365 (1.3 mi).
All 8 questions
What schools serve 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City?
Assigned schools: Elementary: North Rich; Middle: Rich; High: Rich. School district: Rich.
What is the internet speed at 495 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City?
This property has a broadband score of 85/100 (Excellent). Best available speed: 500 Mbps download / 100 Mbps upload. Fiber is not currently available at this address. Available providers: CentraCom (500 Mbps, Fixed Wireless); CentraCom (10 Mbps, DSL); HughesNet (100 Mbps, Satellite). Total providers: 6.
Similar Homes
$175,000
1 day on market4 bd · 4 ba · 3,500 sqft · 0.34 ac lot
732 S SPRUCE DR, Garden City, UT 84028
Est. $1,210/mo
$948,800
26 days on market3 bd · 3 ba · 2,950 sqft · 0.53 ac lot
1073 S MOUNTAIN MEADOW DR, Garden City, UT 84028
Est. $5,444/mo
$825,000
was $899,9904 bd · 3 ba · 3,458 sqft · 0.34 ac lot
796 S SPRUCE DR ##26, Garden City, UT 84028
Est. $4,779/mo
$1,500,000
10 days on market4 bd · 4 ba · 4,300 sqft · 0.99 ac lot
646 S EUTAW RD, Garden City, UT 84028
Est. $8,187/mo
$1,245,000
was $1,295,0008 bd · 6 ba · 4,343 sqft · 1.01 ac lot
730 S BALSAMORHIZA RD, Garden City, UT 84028
Est. $7,169/mo
Find your next home
Save homes, see what they are worth and what they could rent for, and work with a local agent.




