- Great Deal (vs Market)
- Price cut 6%
3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley, UT 84321
$305,000
Originally listed at $325,000
Est. $1,838/mo
- Beds
- 2
- Bath
- 1
- Sq ft
- 2,106
- Built
- 1920
Why this home stands out
- Priced 25% below AVM estimate
- 6% price reduction from original list
About this home
Great opportunity with tons of potential! This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers convenient main-level living, with both bedrooms, the bathroom, kitchen, and living space all on the first floor. The unfinished basement provides plenty of additional space and potential for future bedrooms, a family room, bathroom, storage, or other uses. Basement ceiling height is approximately 6'3". Outside, you'll love the large .45-acre corner lot with a spacious backyard, mature trees, fruit trees, grapes, and secondary water-perfect for keeping the yard and landscaping looking great. The property also features an excellent large detached garage and a long driveway with plenty of additional parking for vehicles, trailers, or recreational toys. Major updates include a newer furnace and water heater. With a little love and updating, this home could really shine! Opportunities with this much land, a large detached garage, secondary water, and room to grow don't come along every day. Bring your ideas, make it your own, and take advantage of everything this property has to offer. Schedule your private showing today!
Features
- Fireplace
- Alarm: Fire
- Patio: Covered
Agents
Connect with your buyer agent
Get local guidance on this home from Juston.
Salt Lake County Realtor | Smart Real Estate. Lasting Legacy.
20 yrs experience
Listed by Max Fletcher
Equity Real Estate (Bear River)
MLS #2187560
Your message goes only to Juston.
See the deal analysis, value and rental income
Ask Juston how this home rates as a deal, what it should sell for, and what it could earn as a long-term or short-term rental.
- Deal score
- Estimated value
- Rental income
Schools
Cache- Nibley
Elementary · 2.0 mi
54% proficient - Ridgeline
High School · 1.8 mi
56% proficient - Millville School
K-8 School · 1.5 mi
58% proficient - Ridgeline High School
High School · 1.8 mi
56% proficient - Nibley School
K-8 School · 2.0 mi
54% proficient
Nearby
Recreation
64 / 100- Local Park · Park0.7 mi
- State Park · Hyrum State Park2.1 mi
- Boat Ramp · Hyrum State Park2.8 mi
- Trailhead · Providence Canyon3.2 mi
Show 5 more
- Golf Course · Logan River Golf Course3.4 mi
- Hot Springs · Crystal Hot Springs6.4 mi
- Fishing · Logan River8.2 mi
- Airport · Logan-Cache Airport8.7 mi
- Ski Resort · Cherry Peak18 mi
Everyday needs
76 / 100- School · Heritage School1.3 mi
- Park · Millville South Park1.7 mi
- Gym · Millville pickleball courts1.7 mi
- Restaurant · Sabores1.8 mi
Show 7 more
- Gas Station · Hyrum Chevron1.9 mi
- Bank · Cache Valley Bank2.0 mi
- Grocery · Ridleys/ ACE Hardware2.0 mi
- Pharmacy · Reed's Pharmacy2.0 mi
- Doctors · Dr. Colbys Office2.1 mi
- Fire Station · Hyrum City Fire Department2.1 mi
- Hospital · CBD Oil skin care2.7 mi
Internet
Excellent · 95/100Xfinity
Cable · 2 Gbps
Wi-Fiber Inc
Fixed Wireless · 499 Mbps
Verizon
Fixed Wireless · 300 Mbps
All 11 providers
- XfinityCable2 Gbps250 Mbps
- Wi-Fiber IncFixed Wireless499 Mbps285 Mbps
- VerizonFixed Wireless300 Mbps20 Mbps
- StarlinkSatellite280 Mbps30 Mbps
- HughesNetSatellite100 Mbps5 Mbps
- Viasat IncSatellite100 Mbps3 Mbps
- CenturyLinkDSL60 Mbps5 Mbps
- Blue Spring BroadbandFixed Wireless50 Mbps10 Mbps
- AT&TFixed Wireless25 Mbps3 Mbps
- Rise BroadbandFixed Wireless25 Mbps5 Mbps
- T-MobileFixed Wireless25 Mbps3 Mbps
Home details
Property
- Type
- Residential
- Style
- Single Family Residence
- Architectural style
- Bungalow/Cottage
- Year built
- 1920
- Stories
- 2
- Above grade area
- 1,083 sq ft
- Condition
- Blt./Standing
- Construction
- Other
- County
- Cache
- Zoning
- Single-Family
- MLS #
- 2187560
Costs
- List price
- $305,000
- Original price
- $325,000
- Annual taxes
- $1,311
- Home warranty
- No
Lot and parking
- Lot
- 0.45 ac
- Lot features
- Corner Lot,Sprinkler: Auto-Part,View: Mountain,Wooded
- Garage
- 2 cars
- Covered spaces
- 2
- Total parking
- 6
Systems
- Heating
- Gas: Central,Wood
- Cooling
- Evaporative Cooling
- Roof
- Asphalt
- Flooring
- Carpet,Hardwood,Linoleum
- Appliances
- Ceiling Fan,Refrigerator
- Patio and porch
- Covered
- Water
- Culinary,Irrigation: Pressure,Secondary
- Sewer
- Sewer: Connected
- View
- Mountain(s)
All home details56 details
Property Info
- Property Type
- Residential
- Property Style
- Single Family Residence
- Architectural Style
- Bungalow/Cottage
- Condition
- Blt./Standing
- MLS #
- 2187560
- County
- Cache
- Year Built
- 1920
- New Construction
- No
- Stories
- 2
- Total Rooms
- 7
- Living Area
- 2,106 sq ft
- Above Grade Area
- 1,083 sq ft
- Lot Size (Acres)
- 0.45
- Lot Size
- 19,602 sq ft
- Zoning
- Single-Family
Bedrooms & Baths
- Bedrooms
- 2
- Total Bathrooms
- 1
- ¾ Baths
- 1
Financial
- List Price
- $305,000
- Original Price
- $325,000
- HOA
- No
- Annual Taxes
- $1,311
- Home Warranty
- No
Structure
- Construction
- Other
- Roof
- Asphalt
- Flooring
- Carpet,Hardwood,Linoleum
- Heating
- Gas: Central,Wood
- Cooling
- Evaporative Cooling
- Appliances
- Ceiling Fan,Refrigerator
- Patio & Porch
- Covered
Lot & Land
- Lot Features
- Corner Lot,Sprinkler: Auto-Part,View: Mountain,Wooded
- Topography
- Corner Lot, Sprinkler: Auto-Part, View: Mountain, Wooded
- View
- Mountain(s)
- Waterfront
- No
- Horse Property
- No
Parking
- Garage
- Yes
- Garage Spaces
- 2
- Carport
- No
- Covered Spaces
- 2
- Open Parking
- 4
- Total Parking
- 6
- ADU
- No
Amenities
- Fireplace
- Yes
- Fireplaces
- 1
- Pool
- No
- Spa/Hot Tub
- No
- Inclusions
- Ceiling Fan, Hot Tub, Range, Refrigerator, TV Antenna, Wood Stove
Utilities
- Water Source
- Culinary,Irrigation: Pressure,Secondary
- Sewer
- Sewer: Connected
- Utilities
- Natural Gas Connected,Electricity Connected,Sewer Connected,Water Connected
Schools
- Elementary
- Nibley
- High School
- Ridgeline
- Elementary District
- Cache
Timeline
- Listed
- Jul 29, 2026
- Days on Market
- 29
- Status
- Active
Nibley market
Explore NibleyNibley median
$501,265
This home: 39% below
Days to sell
54
Utah: 70
Homes for sale
60
Price range
$305k – $1.78M
Sale to list
99%
Market
Balanced market
Location
3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley, UT 84321
Open in map searchCommon questions
About 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley, UtahWhat is the asking price for 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley?
3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley is listed at $305,000 ($145/sqft). The original list price was $325,000, representing a reduction of $20,000. This listing is currently active and available for showings.
Is 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley a good deal?
Propaired's AI deal analysis classifies this property as a "Great Deal (vs Market)" with a deal score of 97/100. Key deal signals: Priced 25% below AVM estimate; 6% price reduction from original list. The price is 31% below similar homes in the area. This analysis considers price relative to comparables, days on market, price reductions, and market conditions.
Is 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley a good investment property?
Based on market rental data, this property has an estimated annual rent of $24,320 with a gross rental yield of 8.0%. Net rental yield (after estimated expenses): 5.2%. Estimated debt service coverage ratio (DSCR): 1.08. Investor score: 66/100. These are estimates based on area comparables.
What lifestyle features does 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley offer?
Propaired's AI has identified 1 lifestyle feature for this property: Vineyard & Orchard. The primary lifestyle niche is "vineyard_orchard." These tags are derived from MLS data, property features, and location analysis.
What recreation is near 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley?
This property has a recreation score of 64/100. Nearby recreation includes: Providence Canyon trailhead (3.2 mi); Park park (0.7 mi); Logan River Golf Course (3.4 mi); Hyrum State Park (2.1 mi). Skiing: Cherry Peak (18.3 mi). Utah offers world-class outdoor recreation year-round, from skiing to hiking to national parks.
What amenities and services are near 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley?
This property has an amenity proximity score of 76/100. Nearby services include: Grocery: Ridleys/ ACE Hardware (2.0 mi); Hospital: CBD Oil skin care (2.7 mi); Pharmacy: Reed's Pharmacy (2.0 mi); Dining: Sabores (1.8 mi). Gas station: 1.9 miles. Gym: Millville pickleball courts (1.7 mi).
All 8 questions
What schools serve 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley?
Assigned schools: Elementary: Nibley; High: Ridgeline. There are 4 schools within 3 miles of this property. The highest-rated nearby school is Millville School with a 58% state performance score (1.5 miles away). School district: Cache.
What is the internet speed at 3959 S MAIN ST, Nibley?
This property has a broadband score of 95/100 (Excellent). Best available speed: 2000 Mbps download / 285 Mbps upload. Fiber is not currently available at this address. Available providers: AT&T (25 Mbps, Fixed Wireless); Blue Spring Broadband (50 Mbps, Fixed Wireless); CenturyLink (60 Mbps, DSL). Total providers: 11.
Similar Homes
$500,000
New today5 bd · 2 ba · 2,281 sqft · 0.89 ac lot
3470 S MAIN ST, Nibley, UT 84321
Est. $2,916/mo
$469,500
was $497,5005 bd · 3 ba · 2,548 sqft · 0.50 ac lot
695 W 3480 S, Nibley, UT 84321
Est. $2,695/mo
$729,900
was $749,9005 bd · 3 ba · 3,494 sqft · 1.56 ac lot
4380 S MAIN ST, Nibley, UT 84321
Est. $4,158/mo
$1,785,000
New today3 bd · 2 ba · 2,812 sqft · 26 ac lot
5035 S HOLLOW RD, Nibley, UT 84321
Est. $9,923/mo
$675,000
17 days on market5 bd · 4 ba · 3,874 sqft · 0.26 ac lot
3462 S 620 W, Nibley, UT 84321
Est. $3,981/mo
Find your next home
Save homes, see what they are worth and what they could rent for, and work with a local agent.