• AVM Upside

1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City, UT 84028

$649,000

Est. $3,934/mo

Beds
5
Baths
3
Sq ft
2,630
Built
1996

Why this home stands out

  • Priced 15% below AVM estimate

About this home

Bear Lake views, mountain surroundings, and 2.07 acres in Garden City! Located in the Bridgerland neighborhood, this 5-bedroom, 3-bath home offers 2,630 square feet of living space on two lots totaling 2.07 acres. Set against the hillside and surrounded by mature trees and natural landscape, the property offers a peaceful mountain setting with beautiful views overlooking Bear Lake. Inside, warm wood finishes give the home a comfortable cabin feel, with a wood-plank ceiling extending through the kitchen and main living area. The kitchen features abundant cabinetry and opens to the dining and living spaces, creating an inviting gathering area with plenty of windows to bring in the surrounding scenery. With five bedrooms and three bathrooms spread throughout the home, there is room for family, guests, a home office, or a Bear Lake getaway. Outside is where this property really shines. A large elevated deck provides plenty of room for outdoor dining, relaxing, and taking in the lake and mountain views. The lower-level walkout opens to additional covered outdoor space, and the adjoining lot provides over two acres of mountain property to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a full-time Bear Lake residence or a mountain retreat with room for everyone, this Bridgerland property combines acreage, privacy, space, and views in one of Garden City's beautiful hillside settings. NO SHORT TERM RENTALS ALLOWED

Features

  • Fireplace
  • Gas Log
  • Range/Oven: Free Stdng.
  • Granite Countertops
  • Double Pane Windows
  • Out Buildings
  • Patio: Covered

Agents

Connect with your buyer agent

Get local guidance on this home from Juston.

JP

Salt Lake County Realtor | Smart Real Estate. Lasting Legacy.

KW Utah Realtors Keller Williams (REVO)

20 yrs experience

Salt Lake City, West Valley City
Dedicated buyer representation

Listed by Natalie Hirschi Jacobsen

Bear Lake Getaway Realty

MLS #2183039

Your message goes only to Juston.

See the deal analysis, value and rental income

Ask Juston how this home rates as a deal, what it should sell for, and what it could earn as a long-term or short-term rental.

  • Deal score
  • Estimated value
  • Rental income

Schools

Rich

Home details

Property

Type
Residential
Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural style
Tri/Multi-Level
Year built
1996
Stories
3
Above grade area
1,694 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
Construction
Stone
Subdivision
BRIDGERLAND
County
Rich
MLS #
2183039

Costs

List price
$649,000
HOA
$550 / Annually
Annual taxes
$2,509
Home warranty
No

Lot and parking

Lot
2.07 ac
Lot features
Terrain: Mountain,View: Lake,View: Mountain
Garage
1 car
Covered spaces
1
Total parking
5

Systems

Heating
Forced Air,Propane
Cooling
Natural Ventilation
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Carpet,Hardwood,Tile
Basement
Daylight,Walk-Out Access
Appliances
Dryer,Refrigerator,Washer
Patio and porch
Covered
Water
Culinary
Sewer
Septic Tank
View
Lake,Mountain(s)
All home details62 details

Property Info

Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Tri/Multi-Level
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2183039
County
Rich
Subdivision
BRIDGERLAND
Year Built
1996
New Construction
No
Stories
3
Total Rooms
14
Living Area
2,630 sq ft
Above Grade Area
1,694 sq ft
Lot Size (Acres)
2.07
Lot Size
90,169.2 sq ft

Bedrooms & Baths

Bedrooms
5
Total Bathrooms
3
Full Baths
2
¾ Baths
1

Financial

List Price
$649,000
Original Price
$649,000
HOA Fees
$550
HOA Frequency
Annually
HOA
Yes
Annual Taxes
$2,509
Home Warranty
No

Structure

Construction
Stone
Basement
Daylight,Walk-Out Access
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Carpet,Hardwood,Tile
Heating
Forced Air,Propane
Cooling
Natural Ventilation
Appliances
Dryer,Refrigerator,Washer
Patio & Porch
Covered

Lot & Land

Lot Features
Terrain: Mountain,View: Lake,View: Mountain
Topography
Terrain: Mountain, View: Lake, View: Mountain
View
Lake,Mountain(s)
Waterfront
No
Horse Property
No

Parking

Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
1
Carport
No
Covered Spaces
1
Open Parking
4
Total Parking
5
ADU
No

Amenities

Fireplace
Yes
Fireplaces
1
Pool
No
Spa/Hot Tub
No
Inclusions
Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Washer

Utilities

Water Source
Culinary
Sewer
Septic Tank
Utilities
Electricity Connected,Sewer: Septic Tank,Water Connected

Schools

Elementary
North Rich
Middle School
Rich
High School
Rich
Elementary District
Rich

Timeline

Listed
Aug 31, 2026
Days on Market
0
Status
Active

Media

Property Website
Visit website

Garden City market

Explore Garden City
  • Garden City median

    $525,000

    This home: 24% above

  • Days to sell

    163

    Utah: 70

  • Homes for sale

    162

  • Price range

    $65k – $4.4M

  • Sale to list

    95%

  • Market

    Buyer's market

Location

BRIDGERLAND

1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City, UT 84028

Open in map search

Common questions

About 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City, Utah
What is the asking price for 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City?

1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City is listed at $649,000 ($247/sqft). This listing is currently active and available for showings.

Is 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City a good deal?

Propaired's AI deal analysis classifies this property as a "AVM Upside" with a deal score of 72/100. Key deal signals: Priced 15% below AVM estimate. The price is 4% below similar homes in the area. This analysis considers price relative to comparables, days on market, price reductions, and market conditions.

Is 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City a good investment property?

Based on market rental data, this property has an estimated annual rent of $29,805 with a gross rental yield of 4.6%. Net rental yield (after estimated expenses): 3.0%. Estimated debt service coverage ratio (DSCR): 0.62. Investor score: 48/100. These are estimates based on area comparables.

What lifestyle features does 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City offer?

Propaired's AI has identified 3 lifestyle features for this property: Cabin & Mountain, Scenic Views, Short-Term Rental. The primary lifestyle niche is "cabin_mountain." These tags are derived from MLS data, property features, and location analysis.

What schools serve 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City?

Assigned schools: Elementary: North Rich; Middle: Rich; High: Rich. School district: Rich.

Is 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City in a flood zone?

This property is classified as low. Flood insurance is not typically required but may be recommended. Always verify current FEMA maps as they are periodically updated.

All 8 questions
How does this listing compare to the Garden City market?

1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City is listed at $649,000, which is above the Garden City median of $525,000 by $124,000. There are currently 162 active listings in Garden City. Homes in Garden City sell in an average of 163 days. The average sale-to-list ratio is 94.8%.

What would homeowner's insurance cost for 1535 S MAHOGANY DR #20, Garden City?

Homeowner's insurance in Utah typically ranges from 0.3% to 0.5% of the home's value annually. For a home listed at $649,000, expect approximately $1,947-$3,245/year ($162-$270/month). Get multiple quotes — rates vary significantly by insurer.

Similar Homes

1/6
Active

$799,900

97 days on market

5 bd · 4 ba · 3,472 sqft · 1.17 ac lot

2330 S VALLEYVIEW DR, Garden City, UT 84028

Near SkiingCabin MountainNear Lake+8

Est. $4,648/mo

1/6
Active Under Contract

$795,000

290 days on market

4 bd · 3 ba · 3,060 sqft · 1.02 ac lot

1175 S CHOKE CHERRY DR, Garden City, UT 84028

Single Family Residence

Est. $4,552/mo

1/6
Active

$495,000

34 days on market

3 bd · 3 ba · 2,061 sqft · 1.01 ac lot

650 S LAKEVIEW DR, Garden City, UT 84028

Great Deal (vs Market)Close to SkiingFixer Upper+9

Est. $2,935/mo

1/6
Active

$695,000

was $795,000

3 bd · 2 ba · 2,000 sqft · 2.63 ac lot

769 N LAKEVIEW DR, Garden City, UT 84028

Motivated SellerClose to SkiingEquestrian+9

Est. $3,951/mo

1/6
Active

$649,900

59 days on market

4 bd · 3 ba · 2,481 sqft · 1.00 ac lot

2072 S SWEETWATER PKWY, Garden City, UT 84028

AVM UpsideNear SkiingScenic Views+9

Est. $3,750/mo

Find your next home

Save homes, see what they are worth and what they could rent for, and work with a local agent.