• Price cut 6%

5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray, UT 84107

$679,500

Originally listed at $720,000

Est. $4,096/mo

Beds
4
Baths
2
Sq ft
2,208
Built
1970

Why this home stands out

  • 6% price reduction from original list
  • 73.0 days on market — potential negotiation opportunity

About this home

5138 S Caribbean Way, Murray, UT Tucked-Away Mid-Century Retreat with Golf Course Views & No Back Neighbors Welcome to a rare find in one of Murray's most sought-after up-and-coming neighborhoods - a quiet, tree-lined mid-century enclave where younger buyers have been steadily moving in and renovating, all while keeping the mature trees and walkable charm that make this pocket so special. Set at the very back of the neighborhood, this home backs directly to the golf course with no rear neighbors, giving you unobstructed, ever-changing views right from your back deck. A private gate offers direct golf course access - perfect for morning dog walks right out your back door. The neighborhood itself is a quiet loop with cul-de-sacs and no through streets, so there's no cut-through or random traffic - just neighbors. Inside, the open-concept upper floor is made for hosting, anchored by a massive picture window in the living room framing stunning mountain views. A walkout basement adds even more living space and easy access to the backyard. Every bedroom in the home is generously sized - no cramped, forgettable rooms here. Recent updates give you peace of mind: Brand new AC system and partial ductwork replacement (3 years ago) Newer dishwasher, stove, and refrigerator All new faucets and updated lighting throughout New lawns and a freshly painted deck Huge new shed for extra storage Outside, a 5-car driveway offers plenty of parking with room to expand further if needed. Location is unbeatable: quick access to Van Winkle Expressway means an easy trip into Salt Lake without ever touching the freeway, and canyon access is close at hand for weekend adventures. Quiet, private, move-in ready, and minutes from everything - this is mid-century Murray living at its best. Contact us today to schedule a showing.

Features

  • Fireplace
  • Bath: Primary
  • Great Room
  • Oven: Gas
  • Range/Oven: Built-In
  • Vaulted Ceilings
  • Patio: Open

Agents

Connect with your buyer agent

Get local guidance on this home from Juston.

JP

Salt Lake County Realtor | Smart Real Estate. Lasting Legacy.

KW Utah Realtors Keller Williams (REVO)

20 yrs experience

Salt Lake City, West Valley City
Dedicated buyer representation

Listed by J. Parker Knight

Realtypath LLC (Prestige)

MLS #2179980

Your message goes only to Juston.

See the deal analysis, value and rental income

Ask Juston how this home rates as a deal, what it should sell for, and what it could earn as a long-term or short-term rental.

  • Deal score
  • Estimated value
  • Rental income

Schools

Murray

Nearby

Recreation

69 / 100
Show 1 more

Everyday needs

72 / 100
Show 7 more

Internet

Excellent · fiber · 100/100
  • Utah Telecommunication Open Infrastructure Agency

    Fiber · 10 Gbps

  • Quantum Fiber

    Fiber · 8 Gbps

  • SenaWave

    Fiber · 2.5 Gbps

All 13 providers
  • Utah Telecommunication Open Infrastructure AgencyFiber10 Gbps10 Gbps
  • Quantum FiberFiber8 Gbps8 Gbps
  • SenaWaveFiber2.5 Gbps2.5 Gbps
  • XfinityCable2 Gbps250 Mbps
  • Beehive BroadbandFiber1 Gbps1 Gbps
  • CenturyLinkFiber1 Gbps1 Gbps
  • VerizonFixed Wireless300 Mbps20 Mbps
  • StarlinkSatellite280 Mbps30 Mbps
  • HughesNetSatellite100 Mbps5 Mbps
  • Utah BroadbandFixed Wireless100 Mbps25 Mbps
  • Viasat IncSatellite100 Mbps3 Mbps
  • CenturyLinkDSL40 Mbps3 Mbps
  • AT&TFixed Wireless25 Mbps3 Mbps
  • T-MobileFixed Wireless25 Mbps3 Mbps

Home details

Property

Type
Residential
Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural style
Stories: 2
Year built
1970
Stories
2
Above grade area
1,104 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
Construction
Brick,Cement Siding
Subdivision
INDIAN WELLS
County
Salt Lake
Zoning
Single-Family
MLS #
2179980

Costs

List price
$679,500
Original price
$720,000
Annual taxes
$2,918
Home warranty
No

Lot and parking

Lot
7,405 sqft
Lot features
Fenced: Full,Sprinkler: Auto-Full,View: Mountain
Garage
2 cars
Covered spaces
2
Total parking
6

Systems

Heating
Forced Air,Gas: Central
Cooling
Central Air
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Carpet,Hardwood
Basement
Full
Patio and porch
Patio: Open
Water
Culinary
Sewer
Sewer: Connected
View
Mountain(s)
All home details58 details

Property Info

Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Stories: 2
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2179980
County
Salt Lake
Subdivision
INDIAN WELLS
Year Built
1970
New Construction
No
Stories
2
Total Rooms
11
Living Area
2,208 sq ft
Above Grade Area
1,104 sq ft
Lot Size (Acres)
0.17
Lot Size
7,405.2 sq ft
Zoning
Single-Family

Bedrooms & Baths

Bedrooms
4
Total Bathrooms
2
Full Baths
2

Financial

List Price
$679,500
Original Price
$720,000
HOA
No
Annual Taxes
$2,918
Home Warranty
No

Structure

Construction
Brick,Cement Siding
Basement
Full
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Carpet,Hardwood
Heating
Forced Air,Gas: Central
Cooling
Central Air
Patio & Porch
Patio: Open

Lot & Land

Lot Features
Fenced: Full,Sprinkler: Auto-Full,View: Mountain
Topography
Fenced: Full, Sprinkler: Auto-Full, View: Mountain
View
Mountain(s)
Waterfront
No
Horse Property
No

Parking

Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
2
Carport
No
Covered Spaces
2
Open Parking
4
Total Parking
6
ADU
No

Amenities

Fireplace
Yes
Fireplaces
1
Pool
No
Spa/Hot Tub
No
Inclusions
Storage Shed(s)

Utilities

Water Source
Culinary
Sewer
Sewer: Connected
Utilities
Natural Gas Connected,Electricity Connected,Sewer Connected,Water Connected

Schools

Elementary
Parkside
Middle School
Hillcrest
High School
Murray
Elementary District
Murray

Timeline

Listed
Aug 20, 2026
Days on Market
68
Status
Active

Murray market

Explore Murray
  • Murray median

    $530,000

    This home: 28% above

  • Days to sell

    59

    Utah: 70

  • Homes for sale

    159

  • Price range

    $210k – $10.65M

  • Sale to list

    99%

  • Market

    Buyer's market

SafetyHigh Crime · 80.9 incidents per 1,000 residents · 74% above the Utah average

Safety rating 1.0 out of 10.

Violent

14.9

per 1,000 · national 3.6

Property

57.8

per 1,000 · national 17.6

vs Utah

+74%

46.4 per 1,000 statewide

vs Salt Lake

+20%

67.5 per 1,000 countywide

Society

8.1

per 1,000

Population 49,238 · 2024 reports · Local rates use NIBRS; national rates use FBI UCR index crimes, which count fewer offense types.

Location

INDIAN WELLS

5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray, UT 84107

Open in map search

Common questions

About 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray, Utah
What is the asking price for 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray?

5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray is listed at $679,500 ($308/sqft). The original list price was $720,000, representing a reduction of $40,500. This listing is currently active and available for showings.

Is 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray a good deal?

Propaired's AI deal analysis classifies this property as a "Standard" with a deal score of 60/100. Key deal signals: 6% price reduction from original list; 73.0 days on market — potential negotiation opportunity. The price is 18% above similar homes in the area. This analysis considers price relative to comparables, days on market, price reductions, and market conditions.

Is 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray a good investment property?

Based on market rental data, this property has an estimated annual rent of $33,950 with a gross rental yield of 5.0%. Net rental yield (after estimated expenses): 3.3%. Estimated debt service coverage ratio (DSCR): 0.68. Investor score: 25/100. These are estimates based on area comparables.

What lifestyle features does 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray offer?

Propaired's AI has identified 6 lifestyle features for this property: Golf Community, Scenic Views, Gated Community, Historic & Character, New Construction, Pet Friendly. The primary lifestyle niche is "golf_community." These tags are derived from MLS data, property features, and location analysis.

What recreation is near 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray?

This property has a recreation score of 69/100. Nearby recreation includes: Arrowhead Park trailhead (1.7 mi); Murray Park park (0.3 mi); Mick Riley Golf Course (0.2 mi); This Is The Place Heritage Park (7.2 mi). Skiing: Snowbird Ski and Summer Resort (12.6 mi). Utah offers world-class outdoor recreation year-round, from skiing to hiking to national parks.

What amenities and services are near 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray?

This property has an amenity proximity score of 72/100. Nearby services include: Grocery: Ma & Paws Bakery...& DIY Dog Wash (2.8 mi); Hospital: Salt Lake Surgical Center (1.8 mi); Pharmacy: Walgreens Pharmacy (2.9 mi); Dining: Denny's (3.2 mi). Gas station: 2.9 miles. Gym: Epic Fitness (3.3 mi).

All 8 questions
What schools serve 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray?

Assigned schools: Elementary: Parkside; Middle: Hillcrest; High: Murray. There are 7 schools within 3 miles of this property. The highest-rated nearby school is Viewmont School with a 58% state performance score (2.7 miles away). School district: Murray.

What is the internet speed at 5138 S CARIBBEAN WAY, Murray?

This property has a broadband score of 100/100 (Excellent). Best available speed: 10000 Mbps download / 10000 Mbps upload. Fiber internet is available at this address. Available providers: AT&T (25 Mbps, Fixed Wireless); Beehive Broadband (1000 Mbps, Fiber); CenturyLink (1000 Mbps, Fiber). Total providers: 13.

Similar Homes

1/6
Active

$610,000

was $649,500

4 bd · 2 ba · 2,400 sqft · 7,841 sqft lot

5580 S 235 E, Murray, UT 84107

Historic CharacterNear State ParkNear Trailhead+6

Est. $3,511/mo

1/6
Active

$544,990

was $592,000

4 bd · 2 ba · 2,342 sqft · 7,841 sqft lot

712 E ARROWHEAD LN, Murray, UT 84107

Golf CommunityNear State ParkNear Trailhead+6

Est. $3,188/mo

1/6
Active

$549,900

was $646,000

4 bd · 2 ba · 2,250 sqft · 8,276 sqft lot

171 E MOUNTAIN VIEW DR, Salt Lake City, UT 84107

Motivated SellerWalkableNear State Park+7

Est. $3,140/mo

1/6
Active

$499,000

was $545,000

3 bd · 2 ba · 2,200 sqft · 10,019 sqft lot

5451 S AVALON DR, Murray, UT 84107

Great Deal (vs Similar)Fixer UpperNear State Park+7

Est. $2,906/mo

1/6
Active

$699,900

New today

5 bd · 3 ba · 2,340 sqft · 9,583 sqft lot

5135 S 1000 E, Murray, UT 84117

Near State ParkNear TrailheadNear Park+5

Est. $4,033/mo

Find your next home

Save homes, see what they are worth and what they could rent for, and work with a local agent.